NASA

The Crew 9 mission came to an end yesterday with SpaceX Crew Dragon 'Freedom' splashing down in the Gulf of America. Photo: NASA

What a long, strange trip it’s been: Butch Wilmore and Suni Williams finally concluded their never-ending story of Boeing’s Crewed Flight Test of Starliner yesterday when they landed in a SpaceX Crew Dragon in the Gulf of America near Tallahassee, Florida. Also aboard were NASA astronaut Nick Hague and Roscosmos cosmonaut Aleksandr Gorbunov, with the four of them designated as Crew 9 on ISS Expedition 71/72.

The Crew 9 mission came to an end yesterday with SpaceX Crew Dragon 'Freedom' splashing down in the Gulf of America.
Photo: NASA
The Crew 9 mission came to an end yesterday with SpaceX Crew Dragon ‘Freedom’ splashing down in the Gulf of America.
Photo: NASA

After a nominal re-entry, the four landed at 5:57 p.m. EDT. Recovery teams on SpaceX vessels secured the spacecraft and assisted the crew while being circled by curious dolphins. Following their arrival on shore, the astronauts began the return procedures: extensive medical checks followed by travel to NASA’s Johnson Space Center in Houston for debriefings and reunions with their families.

Boeing’s Crew Flight Test (CFT) mission was as an 8-10 day demonstration flight for Starliner to validate its capabilities in transporting astronauts to and from the International Space Station. However, technical concerns, including issues with the spacecraft’s propulsion system, led NASA to opt for an uncrewed return of Starliner to conduct further testing and modifications before operational flights could commence.

Starliner CST-100 in launch preparation, May 31, 2024 Photo: Charles Boyer / Talk of Titusville
Boeing CFT, Post-landing
Photo: NASA

For their part, Boeing disagreed with the decision, with the company arguing internally with NASA that Starliner was safe to ferry Williams and Williams back to Earth as planned. That was not to be, as NASA decided to fold the pair into Expedition 71/72 on ISS, and to bump two of the astronauts designated for Crew 9 — NASA astronauts Zena Cardman and Stephanie Wilson — from the mission.

Starliner would eventually return to Earth uncrewed in September, 2024, safely completing its mission via remote control and on-board programming.

Crew 9 Stats

During their missions, Williams and Wilmore traveled 121,347,491 miles, spent 286 days in space, and completed 4,576 Earth orbits. Hague and Gorbunov covered 72,553,920 miles, remained in orbit for 171 days, and completed 2,736 orbits. This mission marked Gorbunov’s first spaceflight. Hague has accumulated 374 days in space across two missions, Williams 608 days over three missions, and Wilmore 464 days across three flights.

Due to the unexpected long-term mission, Williams is now in second place for time spent in space by a female astronaut. Former NASA astronaut Peggy Whitson has accumulated a total of 675 days in space across multiple missions, making her the most experienced astronaut in terms of cumulative days, a record that Whitson will add to she commands the private Axiom Ax-4 mission to ISS later this year.

Curious dolphins circled Crew Dragon as SpaceX secured the capsule.
Photo: NASA
Curious dolphins circled Crew Dragon as SpaceX secured the capsule.
Photo: NASA

Crew-9’s mission included scientific research, maintenance operations, and technology demonstrations. Williams performed two spacewalks, partnering with Wilmore and Hague to remove a radio frequency antenna, collect external surface samples, and install protective patches on an X-ray telescope’s light filters. Williams set a new record for cumulative spacewalking time by a female astronaut, logging 62 hours and 6 minutes outside the station.

The crew conducted over 150 scientific studies and technology tests, dedicating more than 900 hours to research. Their work included plant growth experiments, stem cell technology investigations for treating blood disorders and cancer, and evaluations of circadian rhythm-supporting lighting systems. They also launched the first wooden satellite and studied microorganism survival in space by analyzing external samples from the station.

The mission marked the fourth flight of the Dragon spacecraft named Freedom, previously used for NASA’s SpaceX Crew-4 and Axiom Missions 2 and 3. Following retrieval, the spacecraft will undergo inspections and refurbishments at Cape Canaveral Space Force Station in preparation for future missions.

Shift Change

Crew-9’s comes shortly after the launch and docking at ISS of NASA’s SpaceX Crew-10, which completed the Crew 9 rotation. NASA astronauts Anne McClain and Nichole Ayers;  JAXA astronaut Takuya Onishi and Russian cosmonaut Kirill Peskov will now spend several months aboard Station, and will advance the scientific and engineering work planned for their stay.

Read more

ASA’s SpaceX Crew-9 members pose together for a portrait inside the SpaceX Dragon crew spacecraft while it was still docked to the International Space Station. From left, are NASA astronaut Suni Williams, Roscosmos cosmonaut Aleksandr Gorbunov, and NASA astronauts Nick Hague and Butch Wimore. Photo: NASA

According to NASA, this is standard operating procedure

Butch Wilmore and Suni Williams will be returning to Earth this afternoon aboard Crew 9 after spending some 286 days in space. They and the two other Crew 9 astronauts, Nick Hague and Alexandr Grubonov will begin their fiery descent at around 5:11 PM ET, with a planned touchdown coming some forty-six minutes later at 5:57 PM ET.

NASA said this morning that Crew Dragon will splash down in the Gulf of America, relatively near Tallahassee, Florida.

Suni Williams waves goodbye to crewmates on ISS last night before hatch closure.
Video: NASA livestream

Afterwards, SpaceX will begin recovery efforts on the capsule, leading to the astronauts and cosmonaut exiting Crew Dragon once it is brought aboard SpaceX’s recovery vessel at sea.

As first reported on LiveScience.com, one thing that may surprise casual viewers tuning in to see Wilmore and Williams exit the Crew Dragon capsule is the likelihood that they will be carried in stretchers after leaving the spacecraft. The same may happen with Crew 9 commander Nick Hague and Mission Specialist Alexandr Aleksandr Vladimirovich Gurbonov as well. Both Hague and Gurbonov will have spent 171 days in space when they return to Earth this afternoon.

Wearing their SpaceX pressure suits, Butch Wilmore (l) and Suni Williams (r) post with Nick Hague and Alexandr Gurbonov in ISS shortly before hatch closure on March 17, 2025. 
Photo from NASA livestream
Wearing their SpaceX pressure suits, Butch Wilmore (l) and Suni Williams (r) post with Nick Hague and Alexandr Gurbonov in ISS shortly before hatch closure on March 17, 2025.
Photo from NASA livestream

Talk of Titusville asked NASA for more information, and they replied:

As part of standard procedures, all International Space Station astronauts are placed, or seated, on a mobility aid by recovery teams to assist the crew members returning to Earth’s gravity after several months in space.

After completing medical checks, astronauts are transferred to a waiting helicopter and are taken to a waiting NASA aircraft to return to Houston to be reunited with their friends and families. Then begins the process of post-medical evaluations and reclamation to Earth’s gravity environment.

This process differs for each individual, typically lasting several months, as the longer an astronaut spends in space, the more difficult it is to readapt to gravity. Astronauts returning to Earth after living aboard the space station for extended durations have exhibited balance control problems, muscle weakness, and cardiovascular deconditioning.

NASA’s Human Research Program continues to innovate and pursue the best methods and technologies to keep astronauts healthy during their missions and when they return home. The International Space Station is helping prepare humans for future long-duration missions to the Moon and Mars, including the exercise needed to address the challenges of living and working in microgravity for extended periods of time.

You can view the process during the recovery of NASA’s SpaceX Crew-8 mission, beginning at approximately 1:53:00 into the broadcast.

NASA, March 18, 2025

NASA’s SpaceX Crew-9 members pose together for a portrait inside the SpaceX Dragon crew spacecraft while it was still docked to the International Space Station. From left, are NASA astronaut Suni Williams, Roscosmos cosmonaut Aleksandr Gorbunov, and NASA astronauts Nick Hague and Butch Wimore.
Photo: NASA
NASA’s SpaceX Crew-9 members pose together for a portrait inside the SpaceX Dragon crew spacecraft while it was still docked to the International Space Station. From left, are NASA astronaut Suni Williams, Roscosmos cosmonaut Aleksandr Gorbunov, and NASA astronauts Nick Hague and Butch Wimore.
Photo: NASA

Typically, astronauts aboard the station dedicate two hours daily to exercise in order to counteract bone and muscle deterioration caused by weightlessness. Despite these efforts, Wilmore and Williams will undergo intensive rehabilitation in the coming weeks and months as their bodies readjust to the pull of gravity that almost all of us take for granted as part of our daily lives.

Crew 9 re-entry path from NASA

All four Crew 9 astronauts and cosmonaut will also receive extensive medical checks as part of the crew return procedure, and will also be greeted by family, friends and colleagues after their arrival in Texas.

Watch Crew 9’s Return

Pending weather conditions at the splashdown sites, continuous coverage will resume on March 18 on NASA+ prior to the start of deorbit burn. As of the time of this writing, the schedule provided by NASA calls for:

  • 4:45 PM ET – Return coverage begins on NASA+
  • 5:11 p.m. – Deorbit burn (time is approximate)
  • 5:57 p.m. – Splashdown (time is approximate)
  • 7:30 p.m. – Return-to-Earth media conference on NASA+, with the following participants:
    • Joel Montalbano, deputy associate administrator, NASA’ Space Operations Mission Directorate
    • Steve Stich, manager, NASA’s Commercial Crew Program
    • Jeff Arend, manager for systems engineering and integration, NASA’s International Space Station, NASA’s International Space Station Office
    • Sarah Walker, director, Dragon Mission Management, SpaceX

Read more

butch and suni

The long journey of Suni Williams, Butch Wilmore and the Boeing Starliner mission is finally near its end: If everything goes according to plan, one of the most talked about journeys in American spaceflight will come to an end with a splashdown tomorrow evening somewhere off the coast of Florida.

Sunita “Suni” Williams and Barry “Butch” Wilmore
Photo: NASA

​NASA astronauts Barry “Butch” Wilmore and Sunita “Suni” Williams are set to return to Earth aboard SpaceX’s Crew-9 mission, concluding an unexpectedly extended stay aboard the International Space Station (ISS). The deorbit burn is scheduled for approximately 5:11 p.m. EDT, with splashdown anticipated around 5:57 p.m. EDT off the coast of Florida.​

Unexpectedly Extended Mission

Wilmore and Williams launched to the ISS in June 2024 aboard Boeing’s Starliner spacecraft, initially slated for what was described an eight-day mission. However, technical issues with the Starliner, including thruster malfunctions and a helium system leak, rendered it unsafe for their return. Consequently, the spacecraft returned to Earth uncrewed, leaving the astronauts on Station for an extended period.

International Space Station
Photo: NASA

As a result of the unexpected issues with Starliner, NASA chose to add Wilmore and Williams to the ISS Expedition 71/72 roster. Both astronauts remained active and engaged throughout their prolonged mission, contributing significantly to the station’s objectives, with Williams taking command of ISS itself during her stay. The pair participated in over 150 experiments and observed various Earth phenomena from their unique vantage point. Despite the unforeseen extension, both maintained a positive outlook and never publicly complained about their unexpectedly long mission.

SpaceX’s Crew-9 mission, part of NASA’s Commercial Crew Program, launched on September 28, 2024, from Cape Canaveral Space Force Station’s Launch Complex 40. This mission was notable for being the first crewed launch from this particular complex. The Crew-9 spacecraft, named Freedom, carried NASA astronaut Nick Hague and Roscosmos cosmonaut Aleksandr Gorbunov to the ISS, leaving behind NASA’s three-time space shuttle astronaut Stephanie Wilson and Zena Cardman, with both being reassigned to unspecified future missions.

Crew 9 lifts off from Space Launch Complex 40 on September 28, 2024 Photo: Charles Boyer / Talk of Titusville
Crew 9 lifts off from Space Launch Complex 40 on September 28, 2024 Photo: Charles Boyer / Talk of Titusville

For its part, Crew 9 also experienced several delays prior to launch, primarily due to technical issues with the Boeing Starliner spacecraft and scheduling conflicts with other missions on ISS. Originally planned for mid-August 2024, the launch was postponed to late September to accommodate these challenges. ​

Crew 10

The arrival of SpaceX’s Crew-10 mission on March 16, 2025, marked a significant milestone in facilitating the return of Wilmore and Williams. The Crew-10 spacecraft, carrying NASA astronauts Anne McClain and Nichole Ayers, JAXA astronaut Takuya Onishi, and Roscosmos cosmonaut Kirill Peskov, successfully docked with the ISS, allowing for a seamless transition of responsibilities. ​

The docking occurred at 12:04 a.m. EDT, followed by hatch opening at 1:35 a.m. EDT. The new crew members were warmly welcomed aboard, with the station’s population temporarily increasing to 11. This handover period ensured continuity of operations and allowed Wilmore and Williams to brief their replacements before their departure. ​

Liftoff of Crew 10 on March 14, 2025.
Liftoff of Crew 10 on March 14, 2025. Photo: Charles Boyer / Talk of Titusville

Following the arrival of Crew-10, preparations for the return of Wilmore and Williams intensified. The Crew-9 spacecraft underwent thorough checks to ensure its readiness for re-entry and landing. Both astronauts expressed cautious excitement about returning home, acknowledging the inherent risks associated with re-entry but also their eagerness to reunite with family and resume life on Earth. ​

A Political Football

The extended stay of Wilmore and Williams garnered attention beyond the aerospace community. Public figures, including former President Donald Trump and SpaceX CEO Elon Musk, commented on the situation, with Musk referring to the upcoming return mission as a “rescue” operation.

However, both NASA and the astronauts refuted the notion that they were stranded in space or abandoned, emphasizing that their extended stay was a result of technical challenges and not political decisions. This set off a political firestorm, the intensity of which is rarely seen that involves spaceflight and NASA.

Current Return Plans for Crew 9

As the deorbit burn approaches, scheduled for approximately 5:11 p.m. EDT, mission teams are closely monitoring weather conditions and spacecraft systems to ensure a safe re-entry and landing. The splashdown is anticipated around 5:57 p.m. EDT off the coast of Florida, where recovery teams will be stationed to assist the returning astronauts. ​

Click to open NASA+ for live coverage of Crew 9 activities

In a press release today, NASA said that they and SpaceX met on Sunday, March 16th, to assess weather and splashdown conditions off Florida’s coast for the return of the agency’s Crew-9 mission from the International Space Station. Mission managers are targeting an earlier Crew-9 return opportunity based on favorable conditions forecasted for the evening of Tuesday, March 18. The updated return target continues to allow the space station crew members time to complete handover duties while providing operational flexibility ahead of less favorable weather conditions expected for later in the week.

NASA will provide live coverage of the agency’s SpaceX Crew-9 return to Earth from the International Space Station, beginning with Dragon spacecraft hatch closure preparations at 10:45 p.m. EDT Monday, March 17.

The successful end of the Crew 9 astronauts will finally end a long and controversial mission, and one that NASA surely hopes will never be repeated.

Read more

First Full Successful NASA CLPS Lunar Lander Set To End Mission

A solar eclipse as seen from the lunar surface by Firefly Aerospace's Blue Ghost Mission 1 lander on March 14, 2025
A solar eclipse as seen from the lunar surface by Firefly Aerospace’s Blue Ghost Mission 1 lander on March 14, 2025
Photo: Firefly Aerospace

The first fully successful lunar lander mission in the NASA CLPS program is nearly complete. Lunar sunset at Mare Crisium is expected on March 16, 2025, and without sunlight to power the vehicle’s solar panels, the operations of Firefly Aerospace’s Blue Ghost Mission 1 will end.

This morning on X.com, Firefly Aerospace said

Notably, the last major act of the lander will be to “capture the sunset glow and dust levitation seen by the Apollo 17 astronauts as they were leaving the Moon.” If Firefly engineers are able to capture that rare and only once-seen phenomena, it will be a fitting finale for a thoroughly successful mission.

Do not go gentle into that good night,
Old age should burn and rave at close of day;
Rage, rage against the dying of the light.
—Dylan Thomas

Sunset On The Moon Is A Very Strange Time There

During the Apollo 17 mission, astronauts observed a faint light near the Moon’s horizon during sunrise and sunset, known as lunar horizon glow. This phenomenon is attributed to the electrostatic levitation of lunar dust particles.

On the Moon’s daylit side, solar ultraviolet and X-ray radiation can cause dust particles to become positively charged, leading them to repel from the surface and rise to altitudes ranging from meters to kilometers.

Conversely, on the night side, dust particles acquire a negative charge due to interactions with the solar wind. At the lunar terminator—the dividing line between day and night—intense electric fields may develop, resulting in horizontal dust transport, sometimes referred to as “Moon storms.”

Blue Ghost will attempt to further measure this phenomenon, as it has only been witnessed once, and that some fifty-three years ago.

This Just After A Solar Eclipse

Two days ago, Blue Ghost captured a solar eclipse, albeit the the first one recorded from the lunar surface — on Earth, a lunar eclipse was underway, and the Earth’s shadow was darkening the face of the moon for observers on the ground.

Firefly Aerospace’s Blue Ghost Mission 1 successfully landed on the Moon on March 2, 2025, at 3:34 a.m. EST, near Mons Latreille within the Mare Crisium basin. This mission, part of NASA’s Commercial Lunar Payload Services (CLPS) initiative, delivered ten NASA science and technology instruments to the lunar surface.

irefly's Blue Ghost 1 lander in lunar orbit in February, 2025.
Firefly’s Blue Ghost 1 lander in lunar orbit in February, 2025.
Photo: Firefly Aerospace

Among the payloads, the Lunar PlanetVac (LPV) successfully collected, transferred, and sorted lunar soil using pressurized nitrogen gas. The Electrodynamic Dust Shield (EDS) operated effectively, demonstrating potential applications in mitigating lunar dust accumulation on various surfaces.

The Next Generation Lunar Retroreflectors (NGLR) provided precise measurements of the Earth-Moon distance, contributing to our understanding of the lunar interior and fundamental physics. The Reconfigurable, Radiation-Tolerant Computer System (RadPC) demonstrated resilience to the Moon’s radiation environment, marking a significant step in developing robust computing technologies for space missions.


Blue Ghost Mission 1 cast its shadow on the lunar surface in March 2025
Blue Ghost Mission 1 cast its shadow on the lunar surface in March 2025
Photo: Firefly Aerospace

The Lunar GNSS Receiver Experiment (LuGRE) successfully received GPS and Galileo signals at lunar distances, proving the viability of using these systems for lunar navigation. The Lunar Instrumentation for Subsurface Thermal Exploration with Rapidity (LISTER) measured heat flow from the Moon’s interior, providing insights into its thermal properties.

The Lunar Environment Heliospheric X-ray Imager (LEXI) captured images of Earth’s magnetosphere interacting with the solar wind, enhancing our understanding of space weather phenomena. Additionally, the mission serendipitously captured images of a total lunar eclipse from the Moon’s surface, offering a unique perspective on this celestial event.

NASA awarded Blue Ghost Mission 1 to Firefly Aerospace in February 2021 as part of the NASA CLPS program. The contract was valued at approximately $93.3 million, making Blue Ghost 1 a bargain providing far more scientific returns than it cost.

Read more

It was a good day to have a good day here in Florida, and that’s exactly what NASA, SpaceX and Crew 10 had today at Kennedy Space Center.

Falcon 9 lifted off, carrying three astronauts and one cosmonaut toward orbit and the International Space Station just as the sun was starting to set in the west. Some seven and a half minutes later, SpaceX booster B1090 completed its duty for the day by landing at LZ-1 in Cape Canaveral, 8.8 miles south of LC-39A.

Read more

Crew 10 launch
Falcon 9 rising off of LC-39A Friday evening
Photo: Derek Newsome

It was a good day to have a good day here in Florida, and that’s exactly what NASA, SpaceX and Crew 10 had today at Kennedy Space Center.

Falcon 9 lifted off, carrying three astronauts and one cosmonaut toward orbit and the International Space Station just as the sun was starting to set in the west. Some seven and a half minutes later, SpaceX booster B1090 completed its duty for the day by landing at LZ-1 in Cape Canaveral, 8.8 miles south of LC-39A.

Liftoff of Crew 10. Photo: Charles Boyer
Liftoff of Crew 10. Photo: Charles Boyer

Mechanical issues had delayed this launch, which was originally scheduled for Wednesday, March 12th, but hydraulic issues with ground-side equipment scotched that attempt, with the second launch attempt planned for today. This evening’s attempt was literally picture-perfect, and Falcon 9 rose like clockwork after a quiet countdown.

Press photographers capturing the launch of Crew 10.
Can’t help but cheer: press photographers capturing the launch of Crew 10.
Photo: Charles Boyer, Talk of Titusville

Crew Dragon Endurance is now in orbit, with NASA Astronauts Anne McClain,  Nichole Ayers, JAXA Astronaut Takuya Onishi and Roscosmos Cosmonaut Kirill Peskov aboard. The spacecraft will track down ISS, with docking planned to dock autonomously to the forward-facing port of the station’s Harmony module at approximately 11:30 p.m. ET tomorrow.

Launch Replay

Next Launch

While not officially announced by SpaceX, Starlink 12-16 is expected to launch early Saturday morning.

  • Organization: SpaceX
  • Location: Cape Canaveral SFS, FL, USA
  • Rocket: Falcon 9
  • Pad: Space Launch Complex 40
  • Status: To Be Confirmed
  • Status Info: Awaiting official confirmation – current date is known with some certainty due to information found at secondary sources.
  • Window Opens: Saturday, 03/15/2025 6:28:00 AM
  • Window Closes: Saturday, 03/15/2025 10:59:00 AM
  • Destination: Low Earth Orbit
  • Mission Description: A batch of 23 satellites for the Starlink mega-constellation – SpaceX’s project for space-based Internet communication system.

Crew 10 Launch Gallery

Liftoff of Falcon 9 and Crew 10, March 14. 2025. Photo: Derek Newsome
Photo: Derek Newsome
Liftoff of Falcon 9 and Crew 10, March 14. 2025. Photo: Derek Newsome
Photo: Derek Newsome
Read more

Crew Dragon on top of Falcon 9 at LC-39A, March 12, 2025
Photo: Charles Boyer / Talk of Titusville

Some days you’re the bug, other days you’re the windshield.

The scheduled Wednesday launch of the Crew-10 mission to the International Space Station was scrubbed last night with a little more than forty six minutes left on the countdown clock. The delay stemmed from a malfunction in the hydraulic system of a ground support clamp arm attached to the Falcon 9 rocket, located at SpaceX’s Launch Complex 39A at Kennedy Space Center in Florida.

Crew Safe And Still In Florida

The crew—comprising NASA astronauts Anne McClain and Nichole Ayers, JAXA astronaut Takuya Onishi, and Roscosmos cosmonaut Kirill Peskov—departed the Dragon spacecraft following the cancellation and will remain in Florida for the time being awaiting a new launch window.

NASA Astronauts Anne McClain (left) and Nichole Ayers (right) departing the Neil Armstrong Operations and Checkout Building (O&C) on their way to LC-39A and Falcon 9 on March 12, 2025
NASA Astronauts Anne McClain (left) and Nichole Ayers (right) departing the Neil Armstrong Operations and Checkout Building (O&C) on their way to LC-39A and Falcon 9 on March 12, 2025
Photo: Charles Boyer, Talk of Titusville

The earliest rescheduled launch window is now set for no sooner than Friday, March 14th at 7:06 PM ET in an instantaneous window. That date is dependant on remediations of the hydraulic issue at the launch pad. At this time, the Falcon 9 vehicle itself and the Crew Dragon the astronauts will fly aboard is in good condition.

Weather

Weatherwise, the U.S. Space Force 45th Weather Squadron has not released a new Launch Mission Execution forecast for tomorrow. General forecasts for the Cape are showing a minimal chance of rain with easterly winds between 5-10 MPH with gusts not being a great deal higher than that. Keep in mind that the general forecasts do not consider launch criteria and cover much larger area than the ascent corridor at and above LC-39A, so the 45th may have a different outlook on the probability of acceptable conditions.

Another consideration will be winds and seas along the ascent corridor. That must be within acceptable conditions. Reliable forecasts for winds at the altitudes Falcon 9 will be at are not available at this time. Bottom line: wait for the 45th Weather Squadron’s forecast to draw any conclusions about weather conditions for the launch.

Should the Crew-10 mission proceed on March 14, the preceding Crew-9 team—consisting of NASA astronauts Nick Hague, Suni Williams, and Butch Wilmore, alongside Roscosmos cosmonaut Aleksandr Gorbunov—would undock from the space station NET Tuesday, March 18. That timeline remains contingent on suitable weather conditions at the designated splashdown zones off Florida’s coast and may change over the next few days.

Falcon 9 with Crew 10
Falcon 9 and Crew 10 at LC-39A on March 12, 2025
Photo: Charles Boyer / Talk of Titusville
Read more

Intuitive Machines IM-2 post-landing
Intuitive Machines Nova-C class IM-2 lunar lander "Athena" on its side on the lunar surface. 
Photo: Intuitive Machines.
Intuitive Machines Nova-C class IM-2 lunar lander “Athena” on its side on the lunar surface.
Photo: Intuitive Machines.

Yesterday, Intuitive Machines Nova-C class IM-2 lunar lander “Athena” touched down on the lunar surface safely, but in a position feared to be suboptimal.

Yesterday, Intuitive’s CEO Steve Altemus said in his remarks at a Post-Landing press conference, “We don’t believe we’re in the correct attitude on the surface of the moon.” In other words, not fully upright. Intuitive added that they were working to gather additional data last night and that they would provide an update when the company’s engineers reached solid conclusions.

That update came this morning with Intuitive Machines saying:

Images downlinked from Athena on the lunar surface confirmed that Athena was on her side. After landing, mission controllers were able to accelerate several program and payload milestones, including NASA’s PRIME-1 suite, before the lander’s batteries depleted.

With the direction of the sun, the orientation of the solar panels, and extreme cold temperatures in the crater, Intuitive Machines does not expect Athena to recharge. The mission has concluded and teams are continuing to assess the data collected throughout the mission.

This southern pole region is lit by harsh sun angles and limited direct communication with the Earth. This area has been avoided due to its rugged terrain and Intuitive Machines believes the insights and achievements from IM-2 will open this region for further space exploration.

Intuitive Machines IM-2 Mission Updates, Retrieved March 7, 2025

At this time, it is unclear which, if any, of the instruments other than the PRIME-1 suite the lander carried were able to provide data before the mission’s conclusion. Prime-1, or the Polar Resources Ice Mining Experiment-1 (PRIME-1) was one of the primary activities planned the the IM-2 mission.

Other Experiments Aboard IM-2

Micro-Nova Hopper “Grace”: A drone equipped with a neutron spectrometer, Grace is designed to explore permanently shadowed regions (PSRs) within the nearby Marston crater. Its mission is to provide the first surface measurements of hydrogen in these PSRs, an essential indicator of water presence on the moon.

Lunar Outpost’s MAPP Rover: This commercial rover will autonomously map the lunar surface, capture stereo images, and collect thermal data. It is equipped to inspect samples of lunar regolith, contributing to the assessment of in-situ resource utilization (ISRU) potential.

Nokia’s Lunar Cellular Network: In collaboration with Nokia, the mission will deploy the first cellular network on the Moon, utilizing LTE technology to facilitate efficient data transmission between lunar assets and Earth.

Given that they were not mentioned in the Intuitive Machines update, it is reasonable to assume that those experiments could not be deployed.

This is the second attempt Intuitive has made to land on the moon with their Nova-C lander, with both attempts resulting in successful soft touchdowns but with the lander on its side and unable to complete its experiments fully.

IM-2 Improvements Over IM-1

Dr. Tim Crain
Dr. Tim Crain of Intuitive Machines in yesterday’s press conference after the IM-2 lunar landing. Photo: NASA livestream

In his remarks at yesterday’s joint press conference with NASA, Intuitive Machines’ Chief Growth Officer Dr. Tim Crain pointed out several major improvements to the company’s Nova-C spacecraft:

“They’ve always pointed the old offensive lineman about heavy lifting That’s kind of the way it works sometimes,” Tim Crain began. Crain is a former University of Texas Longhorn football player.

“I’d like to paint a little bit of a picture going back to Valentine’s day of last year when we launched Odysseus. Every day that we went in on that mission, it seemed like that vehicle was just trying to escape our grasp and we had to put out brush fires and understand how the systems we’d built were really working in space. And so every day was a challenge on that mission.”

“And then finally,” Dr. Crain continued, “We ended up on the surface and successfully communicating and operated for many, many days. After the mission, the team got together and we made a list of all the things we had. [We asked outselves] what do we need to change for the next mission? And we had 65 items. 10 were critical, the others were, well, if we can get these in for IM- 2, we will. But if not, they can wait on IM- 3 and it’s probably enough. We got all 65 of those in on this mission. “

“We took a couple of days off after the previous mission,” he said. “Then we got together, we do what we call a hot wash. And the first hot wash I did was on Project Morpheus when I was at NASA when we lost a And then we did a hot wash of all the things we wanted to And eight months later, we’re up and flying better than ever,” Crain said.

“So that was the experience kind of leading into spring of last year, April timeframe. These are all of the improvements that we wanna make. Our orbit determination needed improvement. We had people flying around the world to improve our ground sites to give us better measurements,” Dr. Crain continued.

“We partnered with NASA to have validation and cross- check data to make sure that our systems would work the way they’re supposed to. We had issues that we learned on the way we controlled our engines that we wanted to. Our thermodynamic venting system, could we make that better? Could we make it work the way we want it to work? We ran into problems on the first mission with helium management. Helium is very important to our system for pressurizing our cryogenic methane system, also for RCS.”

“And then we had measurements we wanted to make of craters that we weren’t able to get in place on the first mission. So we had a lot of new technology that we brought forward in this mission. And I’ll be honest, I had a little bit of trepidation when we launched about what some of these new things and improvements might do in the system. It was a night and day operational difference.”

“On day one, we gathered some data about our propulsion system. And then on day two, we fired the better than we’d ever fired it before. The comm systems on our Omni antennas, which aren’t even designed to bring high gain data home, worked better than our high gain antenna had worked on the first mission.”

“We get to the moon, our orbit determination was so precise that we were within a couple ofkilometers in our 100 kilometer orbit. And we didn’t even have to do a lunar correction maneuver that we had put in place, because we had to do one in an emergency on the first mission.”

IM-2 in lunar orbit
IM-2 in lunar orbit.
Courtesy Intuitive Machines

“So it really had moved from come in on the day of operations and save the vehicle to grab your lunch pail, go in, do spacecraft operations, as this magnificent machine called Athena moved her way to the all the way into lunar orbit. And then really the last couple of days in lunar orbit, we were expecting a fully successful landing. We did see some noise on our landing sensors towards the end, our crater recognition system. It’s machine learning on board.”

“How do you tell a computer to look for the craters but identify which craters those are on the moon. [It] worked almost an order of magnitude better than we’d anticipated. So we had every reason to believe that we were gonna come down and land with all systems the way we wanted to.”

“We’re trying to evaluate exactly what happened that very last bit. But I would tell you the improvement from the last mission to the next mission, really in less than a when you consider the fact that you have to be at the Cape early, you have to be done with testing before that.”

“And I’m incredibly proud of the team. I’m incredibly proud of how well this vehicle performed. And I will tell you, the future is bright for intuitive machines to land lots and lots of cargo on the moon.”

Conclusions

Dr. Crain and all of Intutive should be proud of his team and the job that they all did in preparing for and operating this mission. While it may seem on the surface that it was a failure, in fact, it was far from it. Many lessons were learned from IM-1, applied to IM-2 and major improvements were seen. It was also the second flight of a spacecraft fueled with cryogenic propellants, both by Intuitive and both successful. The landing, up to the very last, went well.

Now, Intuitive will assess what happened, devise and test improvements and will apply them to IM-3. The date for that mission is unknown at this time.

About NASA CLPS

Both of the Intuitive Machines missions were part of the NASA’s Commercial Lunar Payload Services (CLPS) program, which is aimed at accelerating lunar exploration by partnering with private companies to deliver science and technology payloads to the Moon. Through CLPS, NASA has awarded contracts to multiple U.S. commercial space firms to develop and operate robotic landers designed to study lunar geology, search for water ice, and test new technologies that could support future crewed missions under the Artemis program. This approach leverages the agility and cost-effectiveness of the commercial sector while advancing NASA’s long-term goals of establishing a sustainable human presence on the Moon.

the moon
A harsh mistress, the Moon.
Photo: Charles Boyer / Talk of Titusville

CLPS is inherently a high-risk endeavor, as NASA is relying on unproven commercial landers to execute complex lunar landings—an area historically dominated by government space agencies with decades of experience. Many of the selected providers are developing their landers for the first time, making each mission an experimental test with no guarantee of success.

Previous attempts by private entities and even national space agencies to land on the Moon have demonstrated how technically challenging it is, with several high-profile failures in recent years and one clear commercial success: Firefly Aerospace’s Blue Ghost, which had a fully successful touchdown earlier this week.

While NASA accepts this risk as part of its strategy to foster innovation, the program’s success is far from certain, and early missions may encounter setbacks before commercial lunar deliveries become routine.

Intuitive Machines IM-2 lunar lander
Intuitive Machines IM-2 lunar lander in a publicity shot. Photo: Intuitive Machines
Read more

Intuitive Machines IM-2 in lunar orbit
IM-2 during its descent.

Intuitive Machines’ confirmed the lunar lander IM-2 Athena, touched down on the Moon at approximately 11:30 a.m. CST on Thursday. That’s the good news.

The bad news, according to Intuitive’s Steve Altemus, “We don’t believe we’re in the correct attitude on the surface of the moon.” In other words, not upright.

Athena becomes the third commercial mission to safely touch down on the lunar surface, albeit with two less than optimal landings. “Any time humanity puts a lander on the moon, it’s a good day,” said Tim Crain, the Intuitive Machines Chief Growth Officer. Crain is right, but undoubtedly he is somewhat disappointed at less than a full success landing of IM-2 Athena.

The scene in Intuitive Machines’ Mission Control
Screen capture of NASA livestream

“[The] IMU data is a piece of data that says that we’re oriented somewhat on our side,” Crain explained later, immediately adding, “I want to get all the measurements to really be able to explain to you the configuration of the [vehicle.] I don’t have a good sense of that today.”

Several hours after the 15-foot-tall robotic lander reached the moon, uncertainty has loomed over its condition. It was unclear whether the spacecraft had executed a stable landing, allowing it to fully carry out its mission as planned, or if it had toppled or partially toppled upon touchdown—an outcome that could hinder its ability to fully deploy it scientific instruments.

Tim Crain of Intuitive Machines
Screen capture from NASA stream.
Tim Crain of Intuitive Machines
Screen capture from NASA stream.

At precisely 12:31 PM EST, Athena successfully touched down near the moon’s south pole. The descent and landing sequence unfolded as planned, with the spacecraft executing an 11-minute engine burn to slow its velocity for a controlled touchdown.

However, in the final moments before landing, flight controllers briefly lost communication with the lander—a disruption expected due to the dynamics of the descent. When contact was re-established, initial data confirmed that Athena had landed and was generating power through its solar panels, albeit not as much as was expected, and an indication that Athena was in less than an optimal state.

Tim Crain summed up his feelings by saying, “I’m incredibly proud of the team. I’m incredibly proud of how well this vehicle performed. And I will tell you, the future is bright for intuitive machines to land lots and lots of cargo on the moon.”

Intuitive has promised more information when it becomes available. This will an interesting mission to watch unfold.

Stay tuned.

Read more